televideoguy
04-28-2008, 06:50 PM
Greetings!
I recently re-loaded PVX on my HP Pavilion and am trying out the Vista compatible version (8.0.4 - easiest way to find it is a Google search - Polycom isn't exactly trumpeting its arrival...). It works great once connected in a call, but I have an intermittent problem connecting to our MGC100 MCU. The status will sometimes show as 'dialing' and never get past that point. After I try a few times and I see the status go to 'ringing' it always connects but the amount of tries varies before it works.
We use the GNU open-source gatekeeper and when I do a Wireshark trace, I can see that although registration is working correctly, sometimes the GK is allowing call setup to proceed and other times it is not. Although it was a while ago when I used it, I now remember seeing this same behavior with PVX 8.0.2 as well. I decided to try connecting to Codian's demo 4500 MCU in California using the IP address for comparison. I get exactly the same results in this gatekeeperless mode as I do with the MGC/GNU setup. Both dialing approaches exhibit the same intermittent connection behavior.
I always seem to be able to connect after a variable number of tries, but am preparing to start supporting a Codian 4220 and a lot of copies of PVX in a pilot project and would like to understand the mechanism behind this behavior - I can't help but wonder if others have observed it as well. I am behind a small PIX firewall - 6.3(5) - on this PC and haven't opened up any incoming ports, but outgoing traffic is wide-open.
I spoke to an experienced network admin at an institution I work with a lot, and he said his installation of 8.0.4 did the same thing for a while, but then the issue went away. I'm interested in hearing any thoughts anyone has about what is causing this behavior.
Thanks!
I recently re-loaded PVX on my HP Pavilion and am trying out the Vista compatible version (8.0.4 - easiest way to find it is a Google search - Polycom isn't exactly trumpeting its arrival...). It works great once connected in a call, but I have an intermittent problem connecting to our MGC100 MCU. The status will sometimes show as 'dialing' and never get past that point. After I try a few times and I see the status go to 'ringing' it always connects but the amount of tries varies before it works.
We use the GNU open-source gatekeeper and when I do a Wireshark trace, I can see that although registration is working correctly, sometimes the GK is allowing call setup to proceed and other times it is not. Although it was a while ago when I used it, I now remember seeing this same behavior with PVX 8.0.2 as well. I decided to try connecting to Codian's demo 4500 MCU in California using the IP address for comparison. I get exactly the same results in this gatekeeperless mode as I do with the MGC/GNU setup. Both dialing approaches exhibit the same intermittent connection behavior.
I always seem to be able to connect after a variable number of tries, but am preparing to start supporting a Codian 4220 and a lot of copies of PVX in a pilot project and would like to understand the mechanism behind this behavior - I can't help but wonder if others have observed it as well. I am behind a small PIX firewall - 6.3(5) - on this PC and haven't opened up any incoming ports, but outgoing traffic is wide-open.
I spoke to an experienced network admin at an institution I work with a lot, and he said his installation of 8.0.4 did the same thing for a while, but then the issue went away. I'm interested in hearing any thoughts anyone has about what is causing this behavior.
Thanks!